Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
[x]

deviantART

 

Debate Topic One - Abortion by ~dA-Debate-Club:icondA-Debate-Club:



What is your opinion on Abortion?

      Pro-Life or Pro-Choice?

  Should all babies have a chance to live, or should
women have the right to control their body?  

  Would it be better to live a life abused or unwanted?
  Or to just not be born?

Is it murder or prevention?

Can it really be considerred murder if a fetus isn't considered to be a human, just tissue?  

and What about Countries with population and STD problems?

Please voice your opinion.
©2008-2009 ~dA-Debate-Club
:iconda-debate-club:

Author's Comments

Leading Opinions
Edit// I have posted the debators gender and age next to their statement to see if there is a trend somewhere.

Pro-life

"saddest thing a person can do to another person, not letting them have the chance to be loved. there are better ways to deal with mistakes besides erasing it.
we've got to give people better living conditions so that they don't have to resort to abortion in the first place--pushing people like young girls to abortion is a sign that our society is so impoverished that we'd rather yell and condemn people for something they feel could be the only way they can protect themselves instead of going through the effort of teaching them about abstinence and being there for them if they make a mistake." ~MeaXMae Female, 19.

"I see that a lot of people here have already voice similar thoughts, but I think that abortion is a viable option when a woman has been raped, is too young to bear the child, or it will endanger her life.
I mean, there are plenty of men and women who want children but are unfortunately unable to conceive who would be perfectly willing to adopt a child. Why not, if circumstances allow, follow the pregnancy to term and put the child up for adoption? It seems a better thing to do than terminate a life that could bring joy to a childless family." ~WazzuOtaku Female, 26.


Pro-choice

"....Either the person would be going through EXTREME EMOTIONAL DRAMA HERE or would be a horrible parent for the child ANYWAY!...As for adoption That's all very nice but there are tons of children who need families too... I know it sounds horrible, but we don't need more parentless kids, we have enough...Yes people must also abuse how 'easy' it is, but for the people who really don't see any other choice it should be there, they've gone through enough...I can only imagine what it would be like to have to pick that." -=Severita Female, 15.


"Irresponsible abortions out of convenience are retarded. That said, we are talking about a fetus. A fetus that is inside of a woman. In my opinion, anyone who tells a woman what to do with her body needs to go play in traffic. Seriously. Any responsible woman will tell you that abortion is the last thing she would want. Even if she's pro-choice. That's what it is: pro-choice. Not pro-abortion. The ability for a woman to choose, for her to decide without interference from a male-driven society. That's what's important. Everyone is pro-life by definition if they are living and breathing. Pro-choice means freedom. Freedom is life." ~conflictfree Male, 20.


"i dont see a problem with abortion as long as its before the baby starts to develop its nerves and the mother isn't using abortion as a constant form of birth control. once is okay, 5 times in the past year is not. also, if there's going to be people on the extreme who go as far as to say a fertilized egg is already a human and deserves this, that and the other things, then why not sperm? why not unfertilized eggs? lets all stop using condoms because you're wasting babies!!" ~RAWR-ima-Dinoroar Female, 16.


Debate (Pro-Life)

"It has the very real potential of being a human. Indeed when is the point where before it was not a person but then it is a person? People may say then why isnt sperm considered etc, but sperm on its own would never be a life, whereas a fertilized egg actually will develop into a human." ~drake124 Male, 17.

Either/Or

"It really depends on the situation. I can't call on a woman automatically and say she's a murderer for having an abortion. My main issue is that a woman shouldn't be allowed to have an abortion if the father wants the child, and the sex was consentual. I think they should both have to sign off on it. I mean, that child is just as much the father's as the mother's. Now if having the baby would cause the mother's death, that's different- but let's face it... we're in the 21st century, and that doesn't happen anywhere near as much as it used to.
Now if the mother gets pregnant often, and continues killing them, then I'm completely against that. It's wrong in all senses of the term. Rape I wouldn't mind the woman having an abortion, but I do know a lot of women who have kept their rape children because it's still their child : /"
-~touchofdestiny Female, 16.

----------------------------------------------------------------
You can either post your opinion in a comment or debate against another person's opinion, by replying to their comment. But make sure you follow the rules:

:bulletred: Watch the Language.

:bulletred: No Flaming or spamming.

:bulletred: No Hate. Respect your fellow debators and their opinions, but feel free to argue with them and respond to their comments.

:bulletred: Please support your opinions and give reasons "why".

Please help spread the debate! We want to hear from everybody's point of view!

~lydia2693

Comments


love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 1 1
:iconmeaxmae:
saddest thing a person can do to another person, not letting them have the chance to be loved. there are better ways to deal with mistakes besides erasing it.
we've got to give people better living conditions so that they don't have to resort to abortion in the first place--pushing people like young girls to abortion is a sign that our society is so impoverished that we'd rather yell and condemn people for something they feel could be the only way they can protect themselves instead of going through the effort of teaching them about abstinence and being there for them if they make a mistake.

btw, pretty bold of you to open this up, I think. Thanks for the invite to rant. God bless

--
Faith is hope without the doubt but with all the trust

******************
Then you rose into my life
Like a promised sunrise.
Brightening my days with the light in your eyes.
I've never been so strong.
Now I'm where I belong.
~Maya Angelou
:iconsyershasfeets:
I hate it when people start skanking it up, getting pregnant right and left and then getting abortions like crazy. . .but I totally understand if you've ben raped and you're really young, or having the baby is going to kill you. It takes a lot to make that sort of decision in those situations I'm sure, and there are definitely better ones in the rape situation. . .but still. It's mostly the situation.

Especially if you're like, 12, and you've been raped AND having the baby's going to kill you. If you're 12 and you got pregnant because you were being irresponsable and REALLY stupid, then that's your own fault.

--
If I had a nickle for every time I blinked, I'd be living on my own island by now.
:icondrake124:
Absolutly justifiable, but needs to be restrained in practice. If ceasing a potential life can save someone who otherwise would lose their lif and ability to fulfill a high quality of life then it is justifiable.

BUT! It shouldnt be used casually. And we should attmept to tackle the problem of underage pregnacies etc at the source. Abortion is a cure for the symptom of the disease and so we must also tackle the cause.
:iconseverita:
CopyPasted from our chat :P

I agree with it. Depending, of course, but I mean...

First off, people act as though the people who go through with one can just go there and say "kill it plz ktks" but think about it:
Either the person would be going through EXTREM EMOTIONAL DRAMA HERE or would be a horrible parent for the child ANYWAY!

As for adoption
That's all very nice but there are tons of children who need families too and sure lives are NOT RUINED by being adopted or something...

But there are also lots of sick kids who have a much lesser chance of being adopted and not all those kids who would have been aborted are going to be sick, many of them likely get adopted faster than children who, say, lost parents, because they're younger and so on and so on.
I know it sounds horrible, but we don't need more parentless kids, we have enough. 

It's a horrible thing, but the world is full of them. And abortions aren't gonna stop with it being illegal anyway
But hell that's not even the point
...Well actually, yes
I'd rather people make it easy and clean then have women sticking hangers up theirs 

Yes people must also abuse how 'easy' it is, but for the people who really don't see any other choice it should be there, they've gone through enough

I can only imagine what it would be like to have to pick that.

--
"Die Sonne hat eben wieder aufs Früchstück geschienen, und ich will nun ans Arbeiten gehen" -Felix Mendelssohn
:iconrawr-ima-dinoroar:
i dont see a problem with abortion as long as its before the baby starts to develop its nerves and the mother isn't using abortion as a constant form of birth control. once is okay, 5 times in the past year is not. also, if there's going to be people on the extreme who go as far as to say a fertilized egg is already a human and deserves this, that and the other things, then why not sperm? why not unfertilized eggs? lets all stop using condoms because you're wasting babies!!


ugh, people these days cant seem to comprehend some of the obvious.

--
join now: ~Unseen-Artists
get your work seen,
and find unknown talented artists
=]
:icondrake124:
I'll make a point against it. It is practically efficient in saving the life of a young mother but ultimatly it is very easy to consider it murder. It has the very real potential of being a human. Indeed when is the point where before it was not a person but then it is a person? People may say then why isnt sperm considered etc, but sperm on its own would never be a life, whereas a fertilized egg actually will develop into a human.
:iconmeaxmae:
who are we to make the projection that a person who was not aborted is going to have a terrible life? kids who were planned could face the same problems within their families as those who could have been aborted, and sometimes kids who are adopted feel no need to find their birth parents because they're happy with the homes they've gotten. statistics may provide a bleak outlook but the kids should decide for themselves what they do...

--
Faith is hope without the doubt but with all the trust

******************
Then you rose into my life
Like a promised sunrise.
Brightening my days with the light in your eyes.
I've never been so strong.
Now I'm where I belong.
~Maya Angelou
:iconatsuyojuunfuyumi:
Im wishy washy on this subject, really.

I believe that, if you're young, and you make a mistake it can be done once... out of fear. One mistake is one mistake.... but that doesnt make it right. Its when its used as a form of birth control, that it deeply bothers me. But if a teen ACCIDENTLY got pregnant, even when using precautions, or a woman was raped, or it could be deadly to the mother, I could understand. but abortion is NOT a birth control!

I suppose my opinion on this is simple, yet vulgar.

Its not that babies fault that a woman spread her legs. Respect that you're cradling a life, and that its YOUR fault it's there.

--
Critique me pllleeeeeeaaasseee!
:icontouchofdestiny:
It really depends on the situation. I can't call on a woman automatically and say she's a murderer for having an abortion. My main issue is that a woman shouldn't be allowed to have an abortion if the father wants the child, and the sex was consentual. I think they should both have to sign off on it. I mean, that child is just as much the father's as the mother's. Now if having the baby would cause the mother's death, that's different- but let's face it... we're in the 21st century, and that doesn't happen anywhere near as much as it used to.
Now if the mother gets pregnant often, and continues killing them, then I'm completely against that. It's wrong in all senses of the term. Rape I wouldn't mind the woman having an abortion, but I do know a lot of women who have kept their rape children because it's still their child : /

--
"Forming bonds is infinitely more difficult than breaking them." - Kuchiki Byakuya
-Avatar Base by ~kawaiihannah
:iconwazzuotaku:
I see that a lot of people here have already voice similar thoughts, but I think that abortion is a viable option when a woman has been raped, is too young to bear the child, or it will endanger her life.

I mean, there are plenty of men and women who want children but are unfortunately unable to conceive who would be perfectly willing to adopt a child. Why not, if circumstances allow, follow the pregnancy to term and put the child up for adoption? It seems a better thing to do than terminate a life that could bring joy to a childless family.

--
"Those who dream by night in the dusty recesses of their minds wake in the day to find that it was vanity: but the dreamers of the day are dangerous men, for they may act their dreams with open eyes, to make it possible." - T. E. Lawrence

Details

June 1, 2008
752 bytes

Statistics

41
2 [who?]
561 (0 today)
3 (0 today)

Site Map